Stilton has a strange reputation for a cheese. In 2005 the British Cheese Board ran a week-long study where volunteers ate a small piece of cheese before bed and kept sleep diaries, and Stilton came back with the most reports of bizarre dreams. The study was run by people who sell cheese and had no control group, so it reads more like marketing than evidence, but nobody seems to have tested the claim carefully since.
I came at it in two steps. First I ran chamomile tea on its own for seven nights to set a baseline, and it gave a mild lift in dream recall along with dreams that tended to replay events from that same day. Then I paired the tea with 20g of Stilton for another seven nights. That combination produced more separate dreams per night, and they drifted toward the strange, but it left me unable to tell whether the cheese or the tea was responsible. This run removes the tea so the cheese stands alone.
The protocol stayed the same: 20g of Stilton, eaten plain about thirty minutes before dosing, on five nights at bedtime and the final two at the 3am wake I have most nights anyway.
Recall came in below my normal, which put it under both the chamomile run and the combination, each of which had landed above average. Vividness and the number of distinct dreams were also below average, the lowest of the three runs, and there was no hypnagogic imagery or lucidity at any point. Most mornings I could tell I had been dreaming but could only recover fragments, and what did come back was mundane, the kind of everyday material that rarely sticks. Nothing approached the odd content the combination had produced.
Sleep was below average too, a little better than during the combination but still worse than with chamomile alone. The first few nights involved a lot of waking, and on some mornings I chose not to write dreams down so I could get back to sleep, which makes recall the least reliable measure in this run.
Timing followed the same pattern I saw with chamomile. The bedtime nights were the weakest, and moving the cheese to 3am brought recall back to average and then slightly above it.
My take is that the recall in the combination came mostly from the chamomile, and that on its own the cheese gave me fewer and flatter dreams with none of the bizarre content the cheese board described. The extra dream density in the combination could still be a genuine interaction between the two, or it could simply reflect the broken sleep both runs shared, and a single person over seven nights can’t pull those apart.
There were no lucid dreams. Next I plan to test white Stilton and a cheese with no mold at all, to see whether the blue mold matters.